Cookie banners done properly: what EU and UK regulators require
Reject next to accept, no pre-ticked boxes, nothing set before consent. What the EDPB, the CNIL and UK law actually expect from your cookie banner.
Most cookie banners in Europe are built to get a click on “Accept”, not to ask a real question. Regulators know this, and they have been clear about what a lawful banner looks like. This guide sets out what the EU and UK rules require in practice, and how to check your own site against them.
Two laws, one banner
Two sets of rules meet in a cookie banner:
- The ePrivacy rules (Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive in the EU, PECR in the UK) decide when you may store or read anything on a visitor’s device. That covers cookies, local storage, pixels and similar techniques.
- The GDPR (or UK GDPR) defines what valid consent is, and governs what you do with the data afterwards.
The basic rule: anything that is not strictly necessary for the service the visitor asked for needs consent before it is set. The EDPB’s cookie banner taskforce restated it plainly: by default, no cookies that require consent can be set without consent, and consent must be a positive action by the user.
What “strictly necessary” covers
Strictly necessary means the site cannot do what the visitor asked without it. Typical examples:
- A shopping basket or checkout session.
- Keeping a signed-in user signed in.
- Security and fraud prevention.
- Remembering the visitor’s own cookie choice.
Advertising, retargeting and social media cookies are never strictly necessary. The taskforce specifically flagged sites that label non-essential cookies as “essential”, and said website owners should be able to show why each cookie on that list belongs there.
The rules a banner must meet
Reject must be as easy as accept
A banner with “Accept all” and “Settings”, but no “Reject”, is the most common problem. The EDPB taskforce reported that a vast majority of EU authorities treat the absence of a reject option alongside the consent button as an infringement. The French regulator, the CNIL, has run repeated enforcement waves under the message that refusing cookies should be as easy as accepting them, sending orders to nearly 90 organisations by the end of 2021.
In practice: put “Reject all” on the first layer, next to “Accept all”, in the same size and style.
No pre-ticked boxes
Consent categories in a settings panel must start switched off. The taskforce confirmed that pre-ticked boxes do not give valid consent, citing GDPR Recital 32: “Silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity should not therefore constitute consent.”
No tricks with design
The taskforce listed practices that make consent invalid, including:
- A “refuse” option shown only as a link inside a paragraph of text, without enough visual weight to be noticed.
- A refuse button whose text contrast is so low it is unreadable.
- A banner designed to make visitors think they must accept to use the site.
Scrolling is not consent
Carrying on browsing, scrolling or swiping does not count. The EDPB’s consent guidelines say these actions will not under any circumstances satisfy the requirement for a clear, affirmative action. The CNIL said the same in its 2019 guidelines.
No cookie walls
Blocking your content until the visitor accepts is not free consent. The EDPB’s consent guidelines state that access to services must not be made conditional on accepting cookies, and give a blocked-content banner as an example of invalid consent.
“Legitimate interest” does not replace consent
Some banners ask for consent and then, deeper in the settings, list the same tracking under “legitimate interest”, switched on. The taskforce confirmed that legitimate interest cannot be the legal basis for placing or reading cookies.
Withdrawing must be as easy as giving
Visitors must be able to change their mind at any time, as easily as they said yes. The taskforce suggests a small, permanently visible icon or a link in a standard place, such as the footer, that reopens the settings.
Keep proof
You must be able to show that consent was given. The CNIL’s guidelines say operators must be able to prove it. A consent tool should log the choice, the date and the version of the banner shown.
The UK is now slightly different
Since 5 February 2026, UK law (PECR, as amended by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025) includes new exceptions in Schedule A1. Cookies used only to collect statistics on how your site is used, in order to improve it, no longer need opt-in consent, provided:
- the data is not shared except to help make those improvements,
- visitors get clear and comprehensive information about it, and
- visitors have a simple, free way to object, and have not objected.
A similar exception covers cookies used only to adapt how the site looks or works to the visitor’s preferences. Advertising and cross-site tracking still need consent.
In the EU, analytics cookies generally still need consent. Some national regulators allow narrow exemptions: the CNIL, for example, accepts consent-free audience measurement only under strict conditions, such as a single-site scope, truncated IP addresses and a 13-month cookie lifetime.
A 10-minute check of your own banner
Open your site in a private window and work through this list:
- Before you click anything, is the site free of analytics and advertising cookies? (Developer tools, Application tab, Cookies.)
- Is “Reject all” on the first screen, as visible as “Accept all”?
- Click “Reject all”. Reload. Is the site still free of analytics and advertising cookies?
- Open the settings panel. Is every optional category switched off by default?
- Is every tracking toggle under “legitimate interest” switched off, or absent?
- Can you reopen the settings from every page?
- Does the content stay usable if you ignore the banner?
- Does your cookie list match what the browser actually shows?
Every answer should be yes. Any no is something to fix.
The simplest fix
The best banner is a small one. Every tracker you remove is one less thing to ask about. If your site only uses strictly necessary cookies, you may not need a consent banner at all, just clear information in your privacy notice.
General guidance, not legal advice.
Where EWC can help
Our general cybersecurity assessment checks your website’s cookie settings and the data it exposes publicly, and tells you what to fix first.
Sources
What this article is based on.
6 sources- European Data Protection BoardReport of the work undertaken by the Cookie Banner Taskforceedpb.europa.eu
- European Data Protection BoardGuidelines 05/2020 on consent under Regulation 2016/679edpb.europa.eu
- CNILRefusing cookies should be as easy as accepting them: the CNIL continues its action and issues new orderscnil.fr
- CNILCookies and other tracking devices: the CNIL publishes new guidelinescnil.fr
- CNILSheet n°16: Use analytics on your websites and applicationscnil.fr
- legislation.gov.ukThe Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, Schedule A1legislation.gov.uk


